Don't Teach Your Kids this Stuff. Please?
Scott McLeod is a professor at the University of Kentucky and is the fellow that created the Did You Know? videos on YouTube that show insane facts about the world's population and percents usually relating to technology.
Sure, I agree with some of the arguments in this post, but it jumbles so many different aspects of the computer that it essentially makes your case invalid. Using technology for educating is something completely different than personal pleasure. Let's face it, blogs and twitter really are self absorbed. How many people get upset when they realize someone has de-friended them on Facebook. Writing online, learning to search the web, and scan are helpful tools that, yes, children should not be sheltered from. However, I see no reason why a ten or fifteen year old child should be allowed to advertise their lives on a social networking site or be exposed to cyberbullying, sexting, and porn. However, I respect McLeod's decision to let his children do what they want. They'll have a leg up in something in the next couple decades.
iSchool Initiative and ZeitgeistYoungMinds Entry
As a high school student, Travis Allen took the initiative to create something larger than himself. The time, effort, and research he put into forming the iSchool Initiative is apparent. His proposition is for schools to save money by throwing ou books, paper, calculators, maps, and anything else tangible. His solution? The limitless applications all found on a Altoid box sized iTouch. He is now in college and travels across the country proposing his idea to schools, trying to make a difference in education and the environment.
I understand and fully support Allen's whole green initiative. However, I believe that taking everything out of a school besides the teachers and desks (don't worry, those will be gone too in a few years) is not the answer. Along with the limitless educational applications, students can download limitless games, books, and etc. so they will never have to be bored sitting through a class again. Schools are already worried about reading, WRITING, and math scores? Say goodbye to governmental funding. How can students learn grammar with spellcheck within the touch of a button and learn math when a graphing calculator can show you how it's done and give you the answer within one second? Good question. Last point, are the schools paying for these? Because it would make perfect sense to force single parent/low-income families to buy one for five children to be able to participate in class.
Eric Whitacres Virtual Choir
Wow! I love this innovative use of technology. Not only are the singers' voices themselves beautiful, but the quality of each separate then put together is phenomenal. I am a huge supporter of music, and I think the opportunity to take part in something like this would be so great. I also give many props to Eric Whitacres! I cannot imagine the time spent contacting the participants, composing the music, and editing the video could have taken. The product was wonderful!
Teaching in the 21st Century
Finally. A video about using technology in the classroom that is relevant. It suggests that teachers should be utilizing technology not only to "keep up with the times," but to prepare children for a life of problem solving and applying knowledge to everyday life. To analyze and create, not just watch, summarize, and duplicate. Not only to use google, presentations, blogs, articles, and YouTube, but to connect information between all of them.
The idea that stood out most to me was
students do not need to be entertained, they need to be engaged
Last fall in UAB's Global and Community Leadership Honors Program, I came to the realization after 12 years of school that I had never learned to connect information. We were doing field work and community service with an organization of our choice, then researching their website, and the social issue it addressed. We then had to collaborate all of the information to determine the organization's role in the community, if it was effective, and how it related to social, economic, political, and humanitarian aspects in the world as a whole. That is what using technology and making one's mark in the world should be about. It is what I, as a teacher can do to not only introduce my students to the world around them, but allow them to become a part of it, and make a difference. Because after all, they really can, and should be connected. Our world is too small to be stuck in your own community and not to explore. I think this is a concept Roberts understands.
Hi Jenna!
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your blog post! It is very well written! I agree with you about Travis Allen's iSchool Initiative, when I first watched the video I thought it was such a good idea, but after reading your post, you made some very good points! Especially what you said about how "along with the limitless educational apps, students can download limitless games, books, and etc. so they will never have to be bored sitting through class again" I didn't think about this! Also, that the spellcheck would keep them from having to learn spelling and grammar. Thanks for sharing!
Brooke Thompson
Jenna,
ReplyDeleteWell written post!
However, I am not sure if you realized that Dr. McLeod was being sarcastic in is post. If you did, I misunderstood you, but it seems to me that you missed his overall tone.
I find it interesting that you think the schools will be "destroyed" by things like the iSchool initiative. While I agree that the basic skills like writing and math computation should primarily be taught in the traditional manner, I think that using technology to enhance these skills is not only appropriate, but beneficial.
I like how you made sure to state that technology is beneficial, but only if it is able to be applied to the workplace. Mindless games and face-booking are a part of the activity, but not the point. We need to teach children to use technology and help them understand that it is useful for entertainment AND (more importantly) education.
Thanks,
Rebekah Lloyd
Also, make sure to fix your title! =)
ReplyDeleteYou missed the meaning of Dr. McLeod's post. He was being sarcastic.
ReplyDelete"...but it jumbles so many different aspects of the computer that it essentially makes your case invalid." I don't understand this argument.
"Let's face it, blogs and twitter really are self absorbed." Inanimate objects can be "self-absorbed"? I don't think so.
"I see no reason why a ten or fifteen year old child should be allowed to advertise their lives on a social networking site or be exposed to cyberbullying, sexting, and porn." Prove to me that this happens without the person involved taking some action that causes problems. We need to teach students to use tools properly. We will NOT be successful in banning them. I can absolutely assure you of that!
Read my post I'm Scared.
"They'll have a leg up in something in the next couple decades." What do you think "something" means in this sentence?
I think your post is flippant. By that I mean "lacking proper respect or seriousness" which is the definition of flippant in the Merriam-Webster Dictionary. That is not an appropriate approach to take in a post for EDM310.
Dr. Strange,
ReplyDeleteI would have posted this as a comment in my blog, but it would not work no matter how many times I tried and tried signing out and back in.
Believe it or not, I did realize McLeod was being sarcastic. However, I also realize that some people do have these views, and I believe that in many cases, there are much better solutions than more technology.
As for jumbling, McLeod incorporates both using technology for learning and for personal pleasure, which I do not think are necessarily relevant.
As for blogs and twitter being self-absorbed, I must have wrongly assumed that a reader would insinuate I (and McLeod) were speaking about the people using them.
As for young children using social networking, I think it is just that no one has shown them a mature way to use the tools. But, this would come more easily with literal maturity than educating kids in junior high about them. And I fully realize that social networking will, and probably should not be banned. I would not be surprised if something else came out in the next few years to make Facebook and etc. diminutive.
I apologize if I sound flippant. I guess every way I have been raised has made me see- both in my life and the world around me- the necessity of books and pens and paper. I know the child I have helped support in Africa and her classmates would appreciate even a small amount of those things more than we could imagine.